Comments

1. 

   Cassie @ Primitive & Proper

   i like the first option stylistically, but i would go with 3 and here is why….
   they are comfy and when you are in the kitchen they aren't high profile so they won't block your view and you can stil easily chat with who is in the living room.

2. 

   Missy in Texas

   My favorite is the Carlisle. I like that they are comfy. I don't like the first ones because of their height. I feel like it blocks the kitchen area too much.

3. 

   Elizabeth @ The Little Black Door

   I vote for #3 for the same reason as Cassie – it won't block the view into the kitchen. Love your color choice as well.

4. 

   Sarah @ 702 Park Project

   I vote for the the Thurston. They add a bit of elegance without seeming too stuffy. And I love the high backs!

5. 

   Melanie

   I vote #3 for the comfort factor and lower profile. As others have said, the others are beautiful but block the view to the kitchen.

6. 

   Amy

   I love a good tufted anything, period. The Thurston is gorgeous but it blocks your view. Finally, the most important thing is comfort. And really, the comfy ones look just as nice as the others when it comes down to it.

7. 

   meghmajithia

   What is the colour u used in the kitchen and living room. Looks very sootjing. Option 3 for me.

8. 

   Caroline Nolazco

   I love the second ones- maybe with fun pillows so they dont seem so serious? And I'm jealous of your photoshop skills! I always want to do things like that but dont know how lol

9. 

   Cris

   1st or 3rd. Love the neutral colors.

10. 

    Mindy

    I'm with the crowd, I like the first ones, but don't like how they block the view to the kitchen. I'm obsessing over tufting right now, and really want a tufted couch, but if they aren't comfy, I'd nix 'em. I vote number three. Love the color, love the feet, and if they're comfy too, win win.

11. 

    Alexa

    Option 3 in my opinion. They seem the least fussy and the most classic. You won't get tired of them.

12. 

    Erin

    I like the carlise. I think the low profile will help it from feeling closed off from the kitchen. The backs on the first ones seemed too high to me and that the family room would feel cut off from the kitchen. either way, they are all nice looking chairs!!

13. 

    Tara {The Silver Lining}

    Oh I love all 3!!! I love big wingback chairs, but I do agree that option 3 will keep the space open.